Playability: 4
This is one of those scenarios that can be played again and again.
You have a choice to be any part of the army you want. There are many strategy's you can attempt.
Balance: 5
Perfect.
Each team has the same starting conditions.
You must try to find a strategy to out smart your enemies.
Creativity: 4
I have never seen something like this, though there may be something like it, but this is done perfectly.
Map Design: 4
Nice and simple, a map that shows some work.
Resources are laid out in a pretty way, giving it a relaxing look.
Story/Instructions: 3
Has no story.
Doesn't really need one.
Additional Comments:
Not much you could change to make it better that I can think of.