This is my first review so if you believe that i exaggerate sometimes just neglect it. I shouldn't be the one judging here since i lack experience, but i thought it might help this site.
Playability: 4.5
The strongest point in this scenario. No bugs and it didn't crash at all. The gameplay was pretty cool. No building and no creating is just what i like to see in scenarios.Winning a scenario just because you gathered resources and recruited soldiers faster than your enemy is just not my style. The fact that you are defending also pleased me a lot as it made it far more interesting and creative. Finally the .per files seem to have worked extermely well as they kept attacking me from every direction and my ally helped me sometimes.
Balance: 2.3
Em.... What can i say? I played it on hardest the first time and i beat it with both wonders alive(the second hardly survived). This ruined part of the gameplay as i didn't have to destroy the enemies. It was very easy in my opinion. Having them recruiting soldiers might solve this problem because i doubt that they were recruiting anything but warships.
Creativity: 3.7
This scenario is creative, in my opinion. This isn't about another random map, where you have to build and kill. The goals, protecting your fort while hordes of enemies are attacking you, are really exciting. There are also some tricks and hidden units.
Map Design: 4
There is a lot of nicely looking eye candy in this scenario, although most of it is located inside the fortress leaving the rest of the map quite blank. The most important thing however is that the landscape suits perfect to the gameplay and makes a really good atmosphere, if you know what i mean. The fortress is in an advantageous place. The forests and the river are placed exactly where they should be.
Story/Instructions: 2.6
Another weak spot in this scenario. Despite the well-made bitmap it needs further explanation in the instructions section and the objectives although creative aren't so sensible. For example why should we destroy the English only after our wonders are destroyed? And by the time they desrtoy the wonders they will be too strong to be defeated. I just hope
i've made myself understnadable.
Additional Comments:
If you are bored of building and creating towns like me this scenario is designed for you! Download it!