Playability: 1.5
This is a scenario I downloaded and I thought not much of it. I was right. No wonder I downloaded it in under a second. The only thing which gave the scenario away was the name. I didn't expect a huge base with countless Archery Ranges.
Balance: 3
This scenario is easy, since you get 99999 of each resource and it's boring. Just pump out a load of Stone Age Bowmen and take the enemy out. Easy.
Creativity: 2.7
Fort walls block you off, and the huge amount of resources make it boring. Though the unexpected use of Archery boosts the score...
Map Design: 1.4
Poor ES-type map design, though it's better than nothing. Houses and buildings were placed in blocks, which is newbic. Top and bottom of map are the best IMO, but no eye-candies anywhere. An almost blank desert in the middle of the map.
Story/Instructions: 1.3
A couple of lines long, but includes a ReadMe. I-already-know-that type hints. Not much effort was put in, and if you lose you see swear messages, which is very wrong.
Additional Comments:
Don't download this campaign, especially if you want swearing at the end. Bad map design and text.