It was playable, but not anything new or different.
Balance: 1
I built up my forces undisturbed as long as I wanted, with vast resources available. I sent a cav arch recon in force and found the enemy to be only clubmen, which I promptly dispatched.
Creativity: 1.5
Nothing new here.
Map Design: 1.5
Town Center, 5 villies, some interesting cliffs, map is all grass with forest painted with a broad brush, one line of cliffs.
Story/Instructions: 1.5
some.
Additional Comments:
to the Player:
I am afraid I cannot recommend this for a download.
to the Designer:
Thank you for your scenario. Please play some other scenarios with high scores, to see how to make a better scenario.